Connecting the world to reliable power

Selection note

Shunt against permanent magnet excitation

Two arrangements cover most of the machines we supply, and the difference between them is decided by something that does not show on the outside: what the machine does while the board is in fault. If the protection on your board has to discriminate between circuits, this is the decision that matters.

What a self-excited machine does in a fault

A self-excited machine builds its own field from the current in its own stator. That is elegant and it is simple, and it has one consequence worth understanding.

When a fault appears on the board, the voltage the machine is holding up collapses, and with it the field. The machine feeds the fault from its own rotor circuit, and that supply fades as the voltage does. It is enough to clear the fault. It is not enough to let the protection work out which circuit the fault is on.

On a board where only one machine feeds the fault, and where the protection does not have to discriminate, that is perfectly adequate.

What a permanent magnet machine does in a fault

A permanent magnet machine does not depend on a supply that collapses with the voltage. The field comes from the magnet on the rotor, so it stays where it is while the fault is on the board.

The machine keeps feeding the fault rather than letting go, and that is what allows the protection downstream to tell one circuit from another and trip the right one. It is the reason this arrangement is specified where sets run in parallel, and where the board has to coordinate selectively.

The second effect: electronic load

There is another difference, and it matters more often than people expect. Electronic load does not behave like motor load. It steps in a way a motor does not, and it draws harmonics that a motor does not.

A machine that holds its voltage through a step is a different machine from one that does not. The arrangement that keeps its field without a supply is better placed to hold voltage through an electronic step, which is why data centre, telecom and similar applications tend to arrive already knowing which arrangement they want.

What it costs

The permanent magnet arrangement is not free. The magnet and the arrangement around it cost more than the simpler options, and that difference shows in the quotation. For a single set on a simple board, that extra cost is usually not buying anything the project needs.

How to decide

  • Does more than one set work on the board? If so, the field has to be held under fault conditions, and the permanent magnet arrangement is the one to quote.
  • Does the protection have to discriminate between circuits? Same answer, for the same reason.
  • Is the load mostly electronic? Then say so in the requirement. It is the question the arrangement has to answer.
  • None of the above? Then the simplest arrangement is usually right, and we will quote it.
Chat on WhatsApp Business

Ask us

Answers come from published selection notes, not from a catalogue.

Request a quotation

We reply to every enquiry within 24 hours, and a selection scheme follows within 48.